How the Sale of Clubs Constantly Diminishes the Value of the PSL

-

 Franchise hopping, community dislocation, and a league struggling with identity

The Premier Soccer League (PSL) in South Africa is a football product rich in potential—but one that consistently shoots itself in the foot. One of the most corrosive issues plaguing its credibility is the constant buying, selling, and relocation of football clubs. These changes aren’t just boardroom matters—they rip through the soul of the game, undercut long-term fan loyalty, and erode the very identity the league is trying to build.

Club Identity Should Be Sacred—But in the PSL, It’s for Sale

Unlike in traditional football leagues across Europe or even parts of Africa, where clubs are inextricably linked to cities, communities, and deep-rooted histories, the PSL operates more like a stock exchange. Clubs are sold like commodities, and with them, entire histories are erased or rewritten on a whim.

Consider SuperSport United, Free State Stars, Platinum Stars, Bidvest Wits, and Tshakhuma Tsha Madzivhandila (TTM). Each club had its own story—supporters, stadiums, and a place in the football fabric of South Africa. And each was unceremoniously bought, relocated, or renamed into near oblivion. Fans are left with nothing but faded jerseys and broken trust.

The Consequences Go Beyond Sentiment

Football thrives on emotion. When you remove that emotional anchor—when fans can’t be sure their club will even exist next season—you kill the product.

  • Sponsorship confidence dips: What brand wants to associate with a club that might not exist, change names, or move provinces next season?

  • Youth development suffers: Academies become unstable. Local talent pipelines are disrupted when a club moves 800km away.

  • Viewership stagnates: You can’t build tribalism or rivalries when clubs are rebranded every few years. This robs the league of narrative and continuity.

The League’s Brand Is Hurt the Most

In football, perception matters. The English Championship is a second-tier league, but its stability gives it weight. The PSL, despite being a top-flight league, often resembles an amateur startup when clubs disappear or pop up randomly.

This inconsistency weakens the PSL's stature both locally and on the continent. CAF competitions become harder to navigate when clubs with zero pedigree or infrastructure suddenly occupy top-flight spots due to a boardroom purchase.

The Case for a Franchise Freeze

If the PSL wants to be taken seriously, it needs to implement strict regulations against the sale of club statuses. This doesn't mean owners can't sell their clubs—but it must come with stipulations:

  • Name and location retention for a set number of years.

  • Fan and community consultation before a move.

  • Transparent public communication on changes.

  • PSL approval board for any proposed sale—independent of financial gain.

A League Without Roots Will Never Grow

Until the PSL gets serious about preserving club identity, it will continue to struggle. It’s not just about football; it’s about trust, loyalty, and building something that lasts.

Because if a club’s name, history, and home can be sold to the highest bidder, what are fans actually supporting?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Does Cricket Have a T20 Problem?

-
Image
 *** This article was first published in February 2023. It was ahead of India's tour to South Africa, as well as the controversial Proteas squad announcement for the tour to New Zealand in February 2024... *** If there ever was a case of becoming a victim of one’s own success, the sport of cricket can attest to this double-edged sword. Namely, Twenty20 cricket. This shortened form of the game took the sport by storm back in 2003 when English cricket implemented it to regain the waning attention of spectators at stadiums and viewers at home. It made perfect sense, for the Gentlemen’s Game – Test, First-Class, One Day International and List-A – was struggling to hold the attention of fans at the start of the 21st century. There were already more than enough distractions in the day of the average cricket lover to deter them from going to the stadium or plopping down on the coach to see how the Proteas could navigate a particularly tricky lunch-to-tea session against an unexpectedly co...
Read more

Vodacom Bulls vs Hollywoodbets Sharks | Lukhanyo Am and Canan Moodie Light Up Battle Of Loftus Versfeld in United Rugby Championship

-
Image
The much-anticipated Vodacom United Rugby Championship derby match between the Vodacom Bulls and Hollywoodbets Sharks at Loftus Versfeld  failed to live up to expectations. The Bulls swatted aside the currently-dreadful Sharks  44-10 in front of 25 000 or so people in Tshwane, consigning the men from Durban to a sixth defeat in seven outings this season so far. One of the selling points of this encounter were the contests within a contest that match-up, where 2019 and 2023 Rugby World Cup Springboks were pitted against each other across the park in mouth-watering match-ups. While the match was a damp squib in terms of an expected classic, there were several tasty incidents during the game where a Bok one-upped another Bok, as seen in the video above. There were plenty of moments that one could read into that we, as the rugby public, might blow out proportion in overanalysing. For instance, Sharks outside centre Lukhanyo Am put breakout utility flyer Canaan Moodie on his backsi...
Read more